Most reviewers say shipping is fast, packaging is secure, and items match the listings. Many praise autograph authenticity, framing quality, and the simple ordering process. A few mention poor customer service or issues with photo clarity. Several also note quick staff replies and problems that were resolved successfully.
Examples from available reviews (Dec 2021 – Mar 2026).
Shipping was fast and the item was graded by Beckett.
“Fast shipping also graded by Beckett”
The reviewer described the service as terrible.
“Terrible Service”
Reviewer has ordered before but was disappointed by picture clarity and distortion.
“I was dissapointed in the clarity of the picture”
Joe resolved an order issue quickly by exchanging for a better quality item.
“Great customer service!!!!”
Most service comments focus on shipping speed and packaging. Several reviewers say orders arrived quickly and were packed with care. One review describes a notably bad service interaction, and it stands alone.
Many reviewers point to fair prices and good value. They often connect the price to item condition and authenticity. Direct complaints about pricing show up rarely.
Customers describe ordering as easy, with a straightforward checkout. A few mention site usability and navigation, though less often than general praise for the buying process. Many say the items matched their collections and expectations.
Buyers highlight authentic signatures, sturdy framing, and strong overall condition. Several mention third-party grading or authentication details. One reviewer noted photo clarity or distortion, and that comes up infrequently.
Many reviewers mention quick replies and helpful interactions with staff. Several describe staff members who fixed order problems or handled exchanges. Negative feedback about communication is uncommon.
Most reviews show strong satisfaction and plans to buy again. A small group of low ratings stands out against the enthusiastic feedback from most buyers. Overall, the pattern suggests reliable fulfillment with occasional service or item-specific issues.
For each review, the core experience based on original source reviews.
Sources: Trustpilot (40) · Collected.reviews (1) · Quotes shortened · As of: March 2026
I have ordered many items from Sports Integrity over the last few years and have NEVER been disappointed. They have a wide range of products that cannot be found anywhere else. The most recent purchase was a gift for my daughter's graduation and she was thrilled with it. My sister in law was so impressed with the Mike Smith Signed Framed 11x14 Kentucky Derby Horse Racing Photo T.C. 2018 JSA that she asked me to order her two more, one for her home and one for her office. They are always professional, quick to ship, and their prices are great. Thank you Sports Integrity !!!
This page combines submitted experiences with public reviews from platforms such as Google, Trustpilot, etc. Recurring points are summarized without changing the content of reviews.
Sports Integrity runs an online shop selling authenticated sports memorabilia. The selection includes signed jerseys, balls, trading cards, and framed photos. Listings show authentication and condition details when available. Customers order through the website and can reach support by email or phone. When needed, the company uses third-party authenticators and grading services.