Buyers repeatedly praise the rings for their look, fit, and how durable they seem. Several customers mention fast replacements and easy size exchanges. Other reviews describe missing or resealed packages, refunds that never went through, and support that stopped replying. Overall, shoppers like the products, but fulfillment and after-sale help vary widely.
Examples from available reviews (Nov 2021 – Mar 2026).
Ordered three rings; package arrived resealed and rings were stolen.
“the only ring remaining in the cheap, resealed mailer was the free silicone band.”
Returned ring but never received refund and was sent to collections.
“I never received the refund, now I was send to collections to pay for a ring I dont even have.”
Lifetime warranty covered lost ring and replacement shipped same day.
“the replacement ring was sent out the same day!”
Customer loves the ring's color, weight, and durability; service praised.
“Its a perfect gold color and super lightweight and seems really durable so far.”
Service feedback splits between quick fixes and major fulfillment breakdowns. Some reviewers describe same-day replacements and flexible size exchanges handled by staff. Another group reports stolen or missing packages and refund disputes that stayed unresolved and ended up in external collections.
Mentions of promotions and add-ons come up, but not often. A few buyers expected promised gifts or discounts and later said the promotions disappeared without notice. A small number tie the drop in value to refunds that were never processed.
When orders arrived, shoppers say the items matched the photos, fit correctly, and made a good first impression on opening. Others received packages they say were tampered with or resealed, which changed the outcome of the purchase. Several negative experiences hinge on how issues were handled after the sale.
Most product feedback across reviews is positive. Customers point to ring color, a lightweight feel, and construction they describe as durable. Reports of defects or low-quality materials are rare.
A repeated complaint is support going silent and promotions changing without explanation. At the same time, several reviewers credit representatives for clear help with exchanges and replacements. Communication feels inconsistent from one interaction to the next.
Feedback is sharply split between very good and very bad experiences. Many five-star reviews praise product quality and how problems were resolved. Low-star reviews focus on lost items, missing refunds, and little to no follow-up.
For each review, the core experience based on original source reviews.
Sources: bbb.org (10) · Collected.reviews (1) · Trustpilot (1) · Quotes shortened · As of: March 2026
Ordered three rings; package arrived resealed and rings were stolen.
“the only ring remaining in the cheap, resealed mailer was the free silicone band.”
Great quality products and fast shipping; awaiting free gift.
“Absolutely great company, amazing quality and quick shipping!”
Promo removed without notice and customer service didn't clarify.
“I was left in the dark wondering what happened when I didn't receive it.”
Company canceled the wrong promotion and then stopped responding.
“they ghosted me..”
Lifetime warranty covered lost ring and replacement shipped same day.
“the replacement ring was sent out the same day!”
Returned ring but never received refund and was sent to collections.
“I never received the refund, now I was send to collections to pay for a ring I dont even have.”
Customer loves the ring's color, weight, and durability; service praised.
“Its a perfect gold color and super lightweight and seems really durable so far.”
Ordered a ring for Father's Day; looks beautiful and quality.
“Ordered one for my husband for Fathers Day and it really looks beautiful”
Team replaced incorrect size and ring withstands daily wear.
“the team was extremely helpful and accommodating in getting it replaced.”
Ring matched description, fit well, and customer support was great.
“The ring came as pictured, fits and feels incredible and customer support has been great.”
Do NOT purchase anything from this company! I purchased a leather duffle bag on October 29th and was told it would arrive in 2-5 days. It is now November 21st and I still do not have my bag and they will not respond to my emails or phone calls. They were very responsive at the beginning of my order process, but once I had paid for the bag they went completely quiet. If you read any of the other reviews on various websites they all have a very similar story. This is clearly fraud and we should report them to our credit card provider as fraudsters. I am now going to contact the authorities who will hopefully be able to track down this company and stop it from operating.
This page combines submitted experiences with public reviews from platforms such as Google, Trustpilot, etc. Recurring points are summarized without changing the content of reviews.
The Vintage Gentlemen runs an online shop selling men’s vintage-inspired accessories. The selection often includes rings, wedding bands, and leather items like wallets and bags. Product pages usually show photos, size guides, and material details to help shoppers choose. The site takes standard payment methods and offers domestic shipping. It also lists contact options and a returns policy for post-purchase questions.